Buying your first home is one of life’s biggest milestones — and choosing the right neighborhood is just as important as finding the right house. For first-time homebuyers in South and Central New Jersey, the region offers a mix of affordability, accessibility, and lifestyle perks that make it a fantastic place to put down roots.

Whether you’re searching for a family-friendly community, a vibrant small-town atmosphere, or a convenient commute, New Jersey has plenty to offer. Here are 10 standout neighborhoods first-time buyers should keep on their radar in 2025.

Evesham (Marlton)

Recently voted the #1 town in New Jersey, Evesham — often called Marlton — is a top choice for first-time homebuyers. With a blend of suburban convenience, highly rated schools, and plenty of parks, it’s an ideal place for young families. The town also offers a variety of housing options, from starter homes to newer developments.

Why it’s great for first-time buyers: Award-winning reputation, family-friendly amenities, and strong long-term value.

Moorestown

A few years ago, Moorestown was voted the #1 town in the United States, and it’s easy to see why. This historic yet modern community features charming downtown streets, excellent schools, and beautiful homes. While some areas lean more upscale, there are still opportunities for first-time buyers to find their place in this highly sought-after town.

Why it’s great for first-time buyers: Prestigious reputation, vibrant downtown, and a strong sense of community.

Cherry Hill

Known as one of the most popular towns in South Jersey, Cherry Hill is a perennial favorite among buyers. It offers excellent schools, a wide range of home styles and prices, and quick access to Philadelphia. Parks, shopping centers, and family-friendly events make Cherry Hill a dynamic place to live.

Why it’s great for first-time buyers: Accessibility, strong schools, and versatile housing options.

Robbinsville

Located in Mercer County, Robbinsville provides a suburban feel with easy access to both New York City and Philadelphia. It’s a commuter-friendly community with a balance of affordability and charm. The town also has a growing dining scene and parks that add to its appeal.

Why it’s great for first-time buyers: Central location for commuters, community atmosphere, and reasonable home prices.

Medford

Medford offers small-town charm while still being close to larger South Jersey hubs. With tree-lined streets, family-owned businesses, and a strong sense of community, it’s an attractive choice for those who value a quieter suburban lifestyle. Outdoor lovers also enjoy Medford’s proximity to nature preserves and trails.

Why it’s great for first-time buyers: Community-focused living, access to nature, and a mix of housing options.

Haddonfield

Historic and walkable, Haddonfield is one of South Jersey’s most charming towns. Known for its bustling downtown, excellent schools, and historic homes, it’s a great match for buyers who want character and convenience. The PATCO train line makes commuting into Philadelphia especially easy.

Why it’s great for first-time buyers: Walkable downtown, historic charm, and convenient Philadelphia access.

Voorhees

Voorhees offers a suburban lifestyle with modern amenities. With strong schools, shopping centers, and plenty of parks, it appeals to young families. Its variety of housing—from condos to single-family homes—provides good options for first-time buyers looking to get into the market.

Why it’s great for first-time buyers: Diverse housing choices, family amenities, and suburban convenience.

Mount Laurel

Mount Laurel combines safe neighborhoods with excellent schools and convenient access to highways. It’s also close to both Philadelphia and the Jersey Shore, making it ideal for those who want flexibility. Affordable starter homes and a strong community feel make it a standout choice.

Why it’s great for first-time buyers: Safe, affordable, and ideally located near major highways.

Hamilton

Hamilton Township in Mercer County is commuter-friendly with NJ Transit access to both New York City and Philadelphia. It offers a mix of affordable homes, spacious parks, and plenty of community amenities. Veterans Park and local restaurants give it a welcoming, suburban feel.

Why it’s great for first-time buyers: Commuter access, affordability, and family-friendly atmosphere.

Bordentown

Bordentown offers small-town charm with big-city access. Its historic downtown, local shops, and restaurants create a welcoming community vibe. With affordable housing options and easy access to major highways and transit lines, it’s a hidden gem for first-time buyers.

Why it’s great for first-time buyers: Charming downtown, affordability, and excellent commuter location.

Final Thoughts

South and Central New Jersey are home to some of the best neighborhoods in the state for first-time buyers. From the award-winning communities of Marlton and Moorestown to the commuter convenience of Hamilton and Bordentown, there’s truly something for every lifestyle and budget.

At Keller Williams Legacy, we’re dedicated to helping you find not just a house, but a home in the neighborhood that fits your next chapter. If you’re ready to begin your home search, reach out today — your dream home in New Jersey is waiting.